VCard4: Difference between revisions

VCard4 (view source)

1,357 bytes added , 17 August 2010

→‎draft 13 section by section review: section 4.1, 4.4, 5.1, 5.4, 5.5 (reviewed thru end of section 5)

canmove, Confirmed users

2,675

edits

@@ Line 66: / Line 66: @@
 Suggestion: use "NOTE" property instead.
+=== section 4.1 ===
+.1.  TEXT
+Editorial comment:
+Examples use "DESCRIPTION" property - which is not in vCard.
+Suggestion: use "NOTE" property instead.
+=== section 4.4 ===
+.4.  BOOLEAN
+Editorial comment:
+TYPO:
+"boolean": The "boolean" value type is used to express boolen values.
+Should be:
+"boolean": The "boolean" value type is used to express boolean values.
+=== section 5.1 ===
+.1.  LANGUAGE
+Editorial comment:
+Please provide a simple example use of the LANGUAGE property parameter, e.g.
+<pre><nowiki>
+ROLE;LANGUAGE=en:teacher
+ROLE;LANGUAGE=tr:hoca
+See below ALTID property parameter for how associate these two ROLE properties as being alternatives for the same property instance.
+</nowiki></pre>
+=== section 5.4 ===
+.4.  PREF
+Preferred value between 1 and 100 seems a bit arbitrary.
+What is the use-case for this?
+Also, from a synchronization perspective, picking absolute numbers for indicating preference would seem to make little sense, as the values themselves only make sense relative to other values.
+Suggestion: drop this property parameter - it seems like a bad design, and unnecessary.
+=== section 5.5 ===
+.5.  ALTID
+This seems like a good mechanism for publishing multilingual alternatives on a per-property basis.
+I'm interested to see how implementations support this, but overall optimistic about its potential.
 == related ==
 * [[Standards]]