QA/Browser Technologies/2011-12-01: Difference between revisions

From MozillaWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(5 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 13: Line 13:


=== Automation (martijn, John) ===
=== Automation (martijn, John) ===
* Functional Frameworks
** Have plans to look into the following frameworks:
*** Marionette
*** Robocop
*** SL4A code.google.com/p/android-scripting (not a test framework as such but can be fitted - takes care of Android API side stuff I have been doing until now with native java apps)
*** MonkeyRunner/Testdroid recorder http://testdroid.com/product/testdroid-recorder
=== Specialized (naoki) ===
=== Specialized (naoki) ===
* CrashKill :  
* CrashKill :  
Line 35: Line 42:
* been working on test cases and testing tips videos
* been working on test cases and testing tips videos


=== Server (James)===
=== Server (James/John)===
* James
** Fairly quiet two weeks with only a couple maintenance releases that needed to be tested in Production.
** Got John ramped up on all things Sync Server


== Test pilot (tracy) ==
== Test pilot (tracy) ==
Line 41: Line 51:


== BrowserID (james) ==
== BrowserID (james) ==
* One very large release in Beta over the last two weeks:
** Train 14: bug 703596 - QA and deploy BrowserID train-2011.11.17 to production
** (Yes, 14 releases already!)
* All QA, Dev, and OPs work now is focused on launching to OPs environments: Dev, Stage, Test/CI, and Production
* Details: https://wiki.mozilla.org/QA/BrowserID/OPsBuildOut


== Pancake (Naoki) ==
== Pancake (Naoki) ==
Line 59: Line 74:


== WebAPI (John) ==
== WebAPI (John) ==
* Project Status:
** Currently landed:  Battery, Camera, IndexedDB, Vibrator, SMS
** Demoed these to media, blogpost
** Need to add EXIF support to camera app
** Need to add Upgrade scenarios to IndexedDB
** Need to create test pagesL  Sensor/Accelerometer
** Camera landing on Windows soon
* Testing
** need to add coverage matrix/testplans/testcases to all apis except Battery
* App support
** Have Battery APP
** Have Info App
** Need Geolocation/Accelerometer APP


= Round Table  =
= Round Table  =
Line 79: Line 107:
== Raw Notes ==
== Raw Notes ==
<pre>
<pre>
Crowdbot dropped :  
BHAG : getting out the door
new zippity working; pulling together the new zippity
- clarity of questions
Not sure where tony is on the other items.
- Big Hairy Audacious Goals
jbonacci finished his dashboard; link in the past action items section.
- want to be able to define the direction
 
- what are we trying to accomplish as a QA org
BHAG:
- not just the weekly goals
tracy :
- How does a BHAG differ from team goal?
mozmill and tps, we can nearly automate all test cases.
- Let's group them up
need another person or way more time to get this done.
- Products
mobile :
- Automation
automation solutions
- Sync services : automation
engagement / Community
- data to prove it's not ready
browser id :  
- Tool for webkit CSS spidering
automation solutions
- drive cross platform, cross browser automation testing on these products (Browser ID)
engagement / Community
- How can we make this a QA goal? - segrata(?)/pyrmamid
pancake :
- not going to write tests for every app, but maybe a template, or samples of tests
automation solutions
- Need more information
engagement / Community
 
- Communication
Need to get audience for Services side
- Let's have communication with Dev
- who the community is
- what's in our current process that can be improved?
- how to reach out to them
- Fennec : There's couple of broken things in the communication
- it's a little different from client
- triaging bugs
 
- equal amount of say : go/no go , proving with data, etc.
Services need more technical community that's interested in bouncing ideas in hacking and testing which may be tricky
- communication w/ keeping up on test case, test case management
Come up with some ideas for single or small groups through various sites that specialize in server side testing
- leading the edge, rather than trailing the edge
Trying to reach a community, not sure of
- how is that different; how can we do better?
trying to think of what's already running in terms of conferences or community with server ops maybe?
- Bugzilla study work, Dev gets assigned with bugs, -> assigning bugs to QA until they are signed off
hacking community : hacking for security privacy issues.
- Improve by bug workflow and process communication : dev should pass the bugs to QA
 
- better management of flags and follow up.
Again trying to find the people would be hard
- better recommendations (submit tests w/ patches); unit tests
 
For Browser Tech, not sure.
- hard to accomplish each of these goals due to youth of projects (for mobile, sync/browser id, pancake)
- one of the goals for next quarter is to get pancake out
 
Anything for process?
- chance to reset
- figure out the processes : risk areas, etc.
- rotational program for each person for a round robin [ that way we don't get tester fatigue; coverage ]
- newsletter for each group
 
- newsletter : cross training, bi weekly.  based on btech meeting?  should we have it through out.
- try to take as little time as possible to spend on the newsletter
 
- do we need a SLA?  Need to formulate structure for SLA : response to testing ?
- Some kind of more formalized process with the dev


Mobile :
- Robocop would help out with. 
- Community
- exploratory in the beginning, manual verifications of nonautomated tests, remaining 10 %
- how can we get productivity, excitement, etc. from our community
- Crowdtest : martijn Crowdbot ported to native UI? Need agreement from Martijn
- test day : we don't want them to disappear after one day
- Zippity ported already
- how do we get it better?
- Something around Devices? 
- localized test days around the region/world
- Performance : automation, compare against other browser.
- Here's a schedule of test days around the world
- getting community with devices that we don't have ; community device owner
- moderate their own
- getting devices to contributors; people that have devices that we don't have.
- huge goals
- Resources : move 90 % automation? -> verify the automations, migrate tests litmus to automation, write litmus to automation, maintainence, increase in waverly help
- every quarter we can break it down based on regions and helping them out
- if we have some slack we can shift people to identify testing, browser id, etc.
- quarterly goals will get broken down from the BHAGs
- webkit CSS testing
- we want to drive automated tools that people can easily contribute
( http://testdroid.com/testdroid/547/testdroid-recorder-1-1-11-is-out )
- define some sort of metric to raise awareness per product. each team to define metrics
- community dashboard
- device anywhere, fennec work, etc. : limitting
- continue to make what contributive to proactive members like gabriella
- Target community members and mentor them into community leaders
- motivation techniques


Services:
- QA is running a fully integrated Test system, consisted of VM's and physical hardware
- Manual testing
- sync server environments, mix of VMs and physical hardware that's already happening
- test plans and test days, but it's starting with blank page
- could be a scaling thing, in terms of how to cover this?
- maybe have templates or something
- automation picture is bigger?
- have global templates or duielines for creating testplans and testcases [tools]
- cut thing? need tony to check out
- how do we write a test plan
- rest of these seems like processes, which most of them we already starting to do.
- standardize metrics that we collect and results and what data needs to be...
- he wants us to be doing; we have various test environments:  
- metrics team already doing this
- requesting QA have their own environment for testing
- AMO, webteam doing metrics already
- borrowed stuff from Ops team
- certain metrics for each of the products to display to the rest of the world?
- 2012 : make our own sync environment : browser ID environment rather than staging environment
What are the number of bugs, what location of test cases, how many run, for each webapp?
- No server side automation.
- dashboard
- nightly unit testing; that's only nightly?  per train?  not sure if it's nightly testing?
- code coverage
- will soon. on the sync server side it is happening Tarak has it set up
- Browser ID ones are javascript
Cross team cross identify
- sync server side it's python
Firefox + Mobile now
- sync is not moving to pyramid
Next year is going to be different playing game:
- sync is all javascript?  TPS stuff; some kind of nightly test that's being done... disregard.  it's client side.
- OWAs
- What are our goals?
- OWAs is a glue to a lot of projects
- Joint bug tracking systems
- test environment  
- how can we have a SLA?
- we need QA : where do we start?  What's our service agreement
- what framework, services, equipment, schedule, specs, plans, etc.
- quality should be driven from QA not the other way around and an afterthought
- should be testable before having the patch
- some of it is changing the perception amongst the company


BHAG:
- small business, and organizations that are picking up OWA and Browser ID
Need a clearer idea what BHAG is
- need to share resources with noncommunity, nonmozilla emp
- context: for the next year
- this will change how we do QA; new audiences businesses
=> 2 big goals : automation, and community
- pick up a secondary
Since browser ID has started, most of the stuff has been running on VM. They are creating full facing environments for release
- how do we coordinate testing efforts?
for staging, production, dev.  Work in progress.  All 4 environments will be up and running by end of Nov.  (est)
- as other people pick up the product
=> end of Q4 go live
- web app, store.  the apps that go in the store
- should be a similar model
- landing amo, review process, etc. upgrades
- browser ID?
- cross browser will be a big difference
- mozilla backed product has to be useful everywhere in web
- webkit QA
- BHAG for mobile: website compatibility
- webkit css
- structure doesn't work well on these sites; for cross browser
- can we write some tools to spider the sites?
- to throw them out to community and report bugs?
- https://wiki.mozilla.org/Mobile/Evangelism
- website compatibility
- work with evangelism, SUMO, tool to crawl websites and detect webkit css
- spread the testing to community
- Marketting
- Automation : cross platform
- browser id people are having some discussions; AMO, and other teams
- need automation for cross product, cross browser
- selenium 2
- drive cross platform, cross browser automation testing
- have some ideas on how we see ; sense server side testing
- SL4A scripting language
- get stuff from platform API (Android) to get information that we need, need to becareful of privacy
- when we know what information that we want to get, we could potentially get it.
- by working with an automation for frameworks
- need to maintain the system
- Robotium : SL4A python
- http://testdroid.com/testdroid/547/testdroid-recorder-1-1-11-is-out
- Tracy: concern for automation, keeping up with automation?  regression testing?  automation?  Sync?
- mozmill + TPS should be able to automate manual testing that we come up with
- if it's just on Tracy, it's a BHAG on top of everything else that Tracy
- push Tracy to do it for a Quarter or hire someone else
- need framework, what has been done, etc.
- more automation for back features
- w/ TPS it has a listener, so the test cases should be in continuous integration frameworks
- Mobile : BHAG
- automation that's a big outstanding goal
- (moved stuff)
- martijn : crowdbot - getting that for native ui
- crowdsource tools that makes it simple for folks to run for cross-platform products
- results/data/reporting driven
- lower the barrier of entry, compelling and fun
- give them a reason for them to join
- a fun, interesting project
- gaming, social interaction?
- combine them?
- automation of recording and pushing scripts to review for community
- Performance process tools
- eiderticker : recording : need to investigate this BHAG
- Having a simplier for bug submissions on phones
- something that captures the data, screenshots, bugs, etc.
- how to submit bugs


How do we track the community
- BHAG form and context underneath it
=> we have one active community member for mobile team
- need the context for what areas that are being filled in
=> sync no progress as of yet.
- the quarterly goals would be the last step
actionitem: => sync newsletter to be discussed between james/oki
- large goals ideas
- poin pointed specifics
Status : read wiki
- crossbrowser specifcs
- browser id : business QA as well
Round Table : fennec table to make sure that sync and fennec stay in sync.
Are they bundling as two separate applications?
Not sure how it's going to go.
The release of first version of native is sync is a blocker if it isn't there.
- it might not be a hard blocker for having sync there.
- idea is tighter knit strategy for this.
</pre>
</pre>

Latest revision as of 22:42, 1 December 2011

« previous mtg | Browser Technologies Home | next mtg »

Discussion Items

  • BHAG discussion (Matt)

Project Status

Fennec

Execution (kevin, aaron)

  • Mobile
    • Mobile Developers are looking for additional testing in regards to recently landed patches (bug 627842) re: improving font size readability on Firefox for Android. Please file bugs if pages you view have odd looking font inflation (size) issues.
    • Encourage and continue to audit and track testing of feature coverage here.

Automation (martijn, John)

  • Functional Frameworks
    • Have plans to look into the following frameworks:
      • Marionette
      • Robocop
      • SL4A code.google.com/p/android-scripting (not a test framework as such but can be fitted - takes care of Android API side stuff I have been doing until now with native java apps)
      • MonkeyRunner/Testdroid recorder http://testdroid.com/product/testdroid-recorder

Specialized (naoki)

  • CrashKill :
    • reporting using P1 ~ P5 status is over. Using Topcrash, reproducible and QA+ for tracking, not sure how Topcrash/reproducible is going to change anything since that's always the way that it's been done
    • going to start graphing the number of crasher bugs in component areas to raise awareness of crash bugs
  • Performance
    • Automation seems about on par with manual testing for local pages, not sure about automation. Probably need to compute a graph with mean and variance.
    • QA to own testing for the video performance testing; need to talk to Erin about video equipment/current methods
    • initial query of where we can go with tpan/tzoom; possible hooks within Robotium; also need to see how Eideticker might help. Eideticker may be done towards the end of this year.
  • Memshrink :
    • currently nothing to report; need to investigate RSS/Profiling
  • Newsletter
    • Need to talk to Al about emailing through generic email account
    • this week's newsletter to be also tweeted about, posted on yammer, facebook, and several other places (including the normal channels of planet, qmo, btech, mobile)

Sync

Client (Tracy)

  • no client trains
  • been working on test cases and testing tips videos

Server (James/John)

  • James
    • Fairly quiet two weeks with only a couple maintenance releases that needed to be tested in Production.
    • Got John ramped up on all things Sync Server

Test pilot (tracy)

  • new study for broken/incompatible add-ons released.

BrowserID (james)

  • One very large release in Beta over the last two weeks:
    • Train 14: bug 703596 - QA and deploy BrowserID train-2011.11.17 to production
    • (Yes, 14 releases already!)
  • All QA, Dev, and OPs work now is focused on launching to OPs environments: Dev, Stage, Test/CI, and Production
  • Details: https://wiki.mozilla.org/QA/BrowserID/OPsBuildOut

Pancake (Naoki)

  • Project Status:
    • Discover tab implemented and pushed to staging; twitter /facebook login also pushed, but incomplete.
    • Addon implemented; blocking bug of initial bookmark+history being pushed to server bug 679133
    • Addon to get fixed, need server changes to support the change. Once it gets fixed, some retesting and release of the addon with the reset of server to take place.
    • Revamp of concept being worked upon still
  • Testing:
    • Testing has been done on the addon and staging server: see bottom of QA notes
    • Testing environment : Need to setup VM testing environment
  • Automation
    • Unit Test Automation demoed to tchung; need more tests added
    • Selenium test from AMO received, need to port to Selenium 2 and section off the BrowerID login portion for Browser ID (ETA end of next week?)
    • Instruments portion : delayed

WebAPI (John)

  • Project Status:
    • Currently landed: Battery, Camera, IndexedDB, Vibrator, SMS
    • Demoed these to media, blogpost
    • Need to add EXIF support to camera app
    • Need to add Upgrade scenarios to IndexedDB
    • Need to create test pagesL Sensor/Accelerometer
    • Camera landing on Windows soon
  • Testing
    • need to add coverage matrix/testplans/testcases to all apis except Battery
  • App support
    • Have Battery APP
    • Have Info App
    • Need Geolocation/Accelerometer APP

Round Table

Notes

Action Items

Action Items from This Meeting

  • jbonacci and nhirata to discuss at least a sync newsletter if not a btech newsletter

Past Action Items

  • [DONE] mobile team to meet at 1:00
  • [DROPPED] b-tech team: please try out crowdbot for fennec xul; and give feedback
    • martijn : send out link to the crowdbot to the team
  • tchung : talk about impact of other communities in the QA community meeting
  • tchung : give bullets for browser tech on visibility for outreaching; show communities for each individual goals for people.
  • tchung and mevans to talk about crowdbot off line
  • [DONE] jbonacci : dashboard would be good idea. Spreadsheet is fine as well; relevant bugs, status, checklist items.

Raw Notes

BHAG : getting out the door
- clarity of questions
- Big Hairy Audacious Goals
	- want to be able to define the direction
	- what are we trying to accomplish as a QA org
	- not just the weekly goals
	- How does a BHAG differ from team goal?
	- Let's group them up
		- Products
		- Automation
			- Sync services : automation
				- data to prove it's not ready
			- Tool for webkit CSS spidering
			- drive cross platform, cross browser automation testing on these products (Browser ID)
			- How can we make this a QA goal? - segrata(?)/pyrmamid
				- not going to write tests for every app, but maybe a template, or samples of tests
				- Need more information
				
		- Communication
			- Let's have communication with Dev
				- what's in our current process that can be improved?
					- Fennec : There's couple of broken things in the communication
						- triaging bugs
						- equal amount of say : go/no go , proving with data, etc.
								- communication w/ keeping up on test case, test case management
		- leading the edge, rather than trailing the edge
		- how is that different; how can we do better?
		- Bugzilla study work, Dev gets assigned with bugs, -> assigning bugs to QA until they are signed off
			- Improve by bug workflow and process communication : dev should pass the bugs to QA
		- better management of flags and follow up.
		- better recommendations (submit tests w/ patches); unit tests

					
		- Community
			- how can we get productivity, excitement, etc. from our community
				- test day : we don't want them to disappear after one day
				- how do we get it better?
				- localized test days around the region/world
				- Here's a schedule of test days around the world
				- moderate their own
				- huge goals
				- every quarter we can break it down based on regions and helping them out
			- quarterly goals will get broken down from the BHAGs
			- webkit CSS testing
			- we want to drive automated tools that people can easily contribute
				( http://testdroid.com/testdroid/547/testdroid-recorder-1-1-11-is-out )
			- define some sort of metric to raise awareness per product.  each team to define metrics
			- community dashboard
					- device anywhere, fennec work, etc. : limitting
		- continue to make what contributive to proactive members like gabriella
		- Target community members and mentor them into community leaders
			- motivation techniques

						
		- Manual testing
			- test plans and test days, but it's starting with blank page
				- maybe have templates or something
				- have global templates or duielines for creating testplans and testcases [tools]
			- how do we write a test plan
			- standardize metrics that we collect and results and what data needs to be...
				- metrics team already doing this
				- AMO, webteam doing metrics already
			- certain metrics for each of the products to display to the rest of the world?
			What are the number of bugs, what location of test cases, how many run, for each webapp?
				- dashboard
				- code coverage
			
	Cross team cross identify
	Firefox + Mobile now
	Next year is going to be different playing game:
		- OWAs
	- What are our goals?
		- OWAs is a glue to a lot of projects
	- Joint bug tracking systems
	- test environment 
	- how can we have a SLA?
		- we need QA : where do we start?  What's our service agreement
		- what framework, services, equipment, schedule, specs, plans, etc.
		- quality should be driven from QA not the other way around and an afterthought
		- should be testable before having the patch
		- some of it is changing the perception amongst the company

	- small business, and organizations that are picking up OWA and Browser ID
		- need to share resources with noncommunity, nonmozilla emp
		- this will change how we do QA; new audiences businesses
		- pick up a secondary
		- how do we coordinate testing efforts?
		- as other people pick up the product
		- web app, store.  the apps that go in the store
		- should be a similar model
		- landing amo, review process, etc. upgrades
		- browser ID?
		- cross browser will be a big difference
		- mozilla backed product has to be useful everywhere in web
		- webkit QA
		
- BHAG for mobile: website compatibility
	- webkit css 
	- structure doesn't work well on these sites; for cross browser
	- can we write some tools to spider the sites?
	- to throw them out to community and report bugs?
	- https://wiki.mozilla.org/Mobile/Evangelism
	- website compatibility
	- work with evangelism, SUMO, tool to crawl websites and detect webkit css
	- spread the testing to community
	- Marketting
	
- Automation : cross platform
	- browser id people are having some discussions; AMO, and other teams
	- need automation for cross product, cross browser
	- selenium 2
	- drive cross platform, cross browser automation testing
	- have some ideas on how we see ; sense server side testing
	- SL4A scripting language
	- get stuff from platform API (Android) to get information that we need, need to becareful of privacy
	- when we know what information that we want to get, we could potentially get it.
	- by working with an automation for frameworks
		- need to maintain the system
		- Robotium : SL4A python
		- http://testdroid.com/testdroid/547/testdroid-recorder-1-1-11-is-out
	- Tracy: concern for automation, keeping up with automation?  regression testing?  automation?  Sync?
		- mozmill + TPS should be able to automate manual testing that we come up with
		- if it's just on Tracy, it's a BHAG on top of everything else that Tracy 
			- push Tracy to do it for a Quarter or hire someone else
		- need framework, what has been done, etc. 
		- more automation for back features
		- w/ TPS it has a listener, so the test cases should be in continuous integration frameworks
	- Mobile : BHAG
		- automation that's a big outstanding goal
		- (moved stuff)
		- martijn : crowdbot - getting that for native ui
			- crowdsource tools that makes it simple for folks to run for cross-platform products
			- results/data/reporting driven
	- lower the barrier of entry, compelling and fun
	- give them a reason for them to join
		- a fun, interesting project
		- gaming, social interaction?
		- combine them?
	- automation of recording and pushing scripts to review for community
	- Performance process tools
		- eiderticker : recording : need to investigate this BHAG
	- Having a simplier for bug submissions on phones
	- something that captures the data, screenshots, bugs, etc.
	- how to submit bugs

- BHAG form and context underneath it
	- need the context for what areas that are being filled in
	- the quarterly goals would be the last step
	- large goals ideas
	- poin pointed specifics
	- crossbrowser specifcs
	- browser id : business QA as well
Retrieved from "https://wiki.allizom.org/index.php?title=QA/Browser_Technologies/2011-12-01&oldid=375080"