QA/Desktop Firefox/WebRTC: Difference between revisions

From MozillaWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(48 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
See: https://wiki.mozilla.org/Media/WebRTC/Testing for background on automated testing.
See: https://wiki.mozilla.org/Media/WebRTC/Testing for background on automated testing.


== Routine Manual Testing Tasks ==
== Basic Topology ==
The following tasks are essentially mechanical, but at least for now they
need a person. The goal should be to find ways to automate this work.
 
=== Basic Topology ===
The basic topology should include two separate machines on separate networks,
The basic topology should include two separate machines on separate networks,
each with their own NAT. We have some flexibility about which NAT, but
each with their own NAT. We have some flexibility about which NAT, but
Line 15: Line 11:
The following test series should be run, with one machine on each network with Nightly.
The following test series should be run, with one machine on each network with Nightly.


==== Endpoints ====
=== Endpoints ===
* Firefox Nightly <-> Firefox Nightly
* Firefox Nightly <-> Firefox Nightly
* Firefox Nightly <-> Chrome Stable
* Firefox Nightly <-> Chrome Stable
* Firefox Nightly <-> Chrome Canary
* Firefox Nightly <-> Chrome Canary


==== Platforms ====
=== Platforms ===
* Desktop (Windows, Mac, Linux)
* Desktop (Windows, Mac, Linux)
* B2G (Unagi, Peak)
* B2G (Unagi, Peak)
* Android?
* Android


=== AppRTC ===
=== AppRTC ===
Conduct a call for no less than 5 minutes with [http://apprtc.webrtc.org apprtc] resulting in no lag or freezing.
Conduct a call for no less than 5 minutes with [http://apprtc.webrtc.org apprtc] resulting in no lag, no freezing, no audio or video delays, no degradation in quality from the previous revision.
 
==== Weekly Test Matrix Template ====
{| class="querytable"
|-
|
| Windows <version>
| Mac OSX <version>
| Linux <version>
| Android <version>
| B2G <version>
|-
| Windows <version>
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
|-
| Mac OSX <version>
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
|-
| Linux <version>
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
|-
| Android <version>
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
|-
| B2G <version>
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
| Firefox -> Chrome <br> Chrome -> Firefox <br> Firefox -> Firefox
|-
|}
''<version> indicates Operating System version, a different version each week''


=== WebRTC.ME ===
=== WebRTC.ME ===
Line 82: Line 30:
Run the [http://mozilla.github.com/webrtc-landing WebRTC-Landing tests] with no failures.
Run the [http://mozilla.github.com/webrtc-landing WebRTC-Landing tests] with no failures.


== Other Tasks ==
== Known Issues ==
=== FIXED Bugs ===
* {{bug|936034}} - Sound is distorted on one side on 1:1 call
The following tracks verification of WebRTC bug fixes. As you verify a bug fix please list it below.
* [http://mzl.la/196DkC0 549 more bugs]
 
=== UNCONFIRMED Bugs ===
The following tracks confirmation of WebRTC bugs. As you confirm a bug exists please list it below.
* [http://mzl.la/14a3qyW 17 more bugs]
 
=== WebRTC Health Report ===
The following tries to estimate the relative "health" of WebRTC based on bugs in bugzilla. Update this table each week with the number of bugs reported, resolved, and reopened.
{| class="querytable"
| class="header" | Period
| class="header" | Bugs Reported
| class="header" | Bugs Resolved
| class="header" | Bugs Reopened
|-
| 2013.07.28 - 2013.08.03
| 9
| 32
| 4
|-
| 2013.07-21 - 2013-07-27
| 14
| 17
| 3
|-
| 2013.07.14 - 2013.07.20
| 12
| 11
| 2
|-
| 2013.07.07 - 2013.07.13
| 16
| 16
| 2
|-
| 2013.06.30 - 2013.07.06
| 11
| 17
| 3
|}
 
== Testing ==
=== AppRTC ===
* Demo Site: [http://apprtc.webrtc.org/ apprtc.webrtc.org]
* Test Methodology:
** Running the demo 1:1 with no other processes running
** Running the demo 1:1 with another vanilla Firefox process running
** Running the demo 1:1 with another heavy Firefox process running (Flash, videos, games, gmail, etc)
** Restart the caller browser and repeat the above
** Restart the callee browser and repeat the above
* Expected Result:
** A call lasting 5 minutes or longer should be clear and accurate (no delays, no artifacts, no crashes or hangs)
* Platforms:
** P1: Windows XP, Windows 7, Windows 8, Mac OSX 10.8, Ubuntu 12.04, B2G
** P2: Windows Vista, Mac OSX 10.7, Ubuntu 13.04, Android
* Builds:
** P1: Firefox Nightly, Chrome Stable, B2G Browser
** P2: Firefox Aurora/Beta/Release, Chrome Canary, Firefox Android (all branches)
 
==== Results ====
{| class="querytable"
| class="header" style="width:30%" | Caller
| class="header" style="width:30%" | Callee
| class="header" style="width:40%" | Result
|-
| Windows XP w/Firefox Nightly YYYY.MM.DD
| Windows 7 w/Firefox Nightly YYYY.MM.DD
| '''RESULT''': detailed notes
|-
|}


== Activity Log ==
== Meetings ==
* YYYY.MM.DD: Description of what was tested, any bugs filed, etc
* [https://etherpad.mozilla.org/qa-webrtc-meeting-20130814 August 14, 2013]: Kick-off meeting with WebRTC Devs

Latest revision as of 19:27, 7 February 2014

See: https://wiki.mozilla.org/Media/WebRTC/Testing for background on automated testing.

Basic Topology

The basic topology should include two separate machines on separate networks, each with their own NAT. We have some flexibility about which NAT, but for concreteness, I suggest a pair of Apple Airport Express NATs. I.e., the following topology:

Topoplogy.png

The following test series should be run, with one machine on each network with Nightly.

Endpoints

  • Firefox Nightly <-> Firefox Nightly
  • Firefox Nightly <-> Chrome Stable
  • Firefox Nightly <-> Chrome Canary

Platforms

  • Desktop (Windows, Mac, Linux)
  • B2G (Unagi, Peak)
  • Android

AppRTC

Conduct a call for no less than 5 minutes with apprtc resulting in no lag, no freezing, no audio or video delays, no degradation in quality from the previous revision.

WebRTC.ME

Conduct a call for no less than 1 minute using webrtcme resulting in minimal lag and freezing.

WebRTC Landing

Run the WebRTC-Landing tests with no failures.

Known Issues

  • bug 936034 - Sound is distorted on one side on 1:1 call

Meetings