1,926
edits
MDN/Archives/Logo: Difference between revisions
no edit summary
No edit summary |
|||
| Line 43: | Line 43: | ||
*** Don't get the atom concept, so looking forward to hearing the designers rationale | *** Don't get the atom concept, so looking forward to hearing the designers rationale | ||
== Gen's feedback (favorites in bold) == | |||
== | * Comp 1: Flame | ||
** Unclear to me what the flame represents with respect to programming or developers. | |||
* '''Comp 2: Robo Dino''' | |||
** I like the robo dino but don't like the fonts of the MDN much. If we went with this, I'd like to see if the robo dino could be simplified a bit more to make it even more iconic. And a different font. Not sure I can explain what I don't like about it per se- it's just not memorable. | |||
* Comp 3: Pixelated | |||
** I get the idea, and it's cute in a way, but it's also kinda obscure and legibility is poor. Not what I would go with. | |||
* Comp 4: Eye | |||
** Unclear to me what the eye represents. I like this font a bit more than the Robo Dino font. Not what I would go with as it's not immediately clear what this is all about. | |||
* Comp 5: Dino Gears | |||
** If I had to choose, Robo Dino is a bit more compelling for me. I can see the connection with the MDN font here, but maybe its a bit too angular? | |||
* Comp 6: Spidey Sense | |||
** Similar to "Eye" I don't really get it. | |||
* Comp 7: Revolution | |||
** While there are aspects of this iconography that work for me, there are places where this iconography is despised (any Eastern European state that was subjugated by the USSR.) So I think this is actually not appropriate as a global icon as I think it means different things in different places. | |||
* Comp 8: Atom | |||
** Unclear to me. | |||
== Blizzard's Feedback == | |||
* Comp 1: | |||
Nope, not right. | |||
* Comp 2: | |||
Like this one the best. Even like the wrench, which someone else thought was cheesy. Echos of the hacks brand, but has the robot feel. (I like robots!) Also, would look damn good on a t-shirt. An important consideration. Downside is that it looks a little different than just about every other logo and site that we have. But maybe that's OK. Fits into the doc system, though, as black on white is probably something we can build on for the general design for the entire developer site + MDN. | |||
* Comp 3: | |||
Nope. | |||
* Comp 4: | |||
Save that one for Weave! Or Test Pilot! :) | |||
* Comp 5: | |||
Neat, but feels a little too out there. Can't tell what it is at first glance. Also, that dino IS A CYLON. | |||
* Comp 6: | |||
Dude. Wireless. Feels a little bit too much like a set of angel wings. | |||
* Comp 7: | |||
My second favorite after the dino heads. Very protest / old school banners. Doesn't echo the Mozilla brand well, though. Alternate marks are neat, too. | |||