1,926
edits
MDN/Archives/Logo: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
→SNO Concepts Round 1 Feedback (2/3 - 2/4)
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
== SNO Concepts Round 1 Feedback (2/3 - 2/4) == | == SNO Concepts Round 1 Feedback (2/3 - 2/4) == | ||
* Jay's feedback | |||
** Comp 1: Flame | |||
*** I think of "igniting innovation" | |||
*** I see the letters mdn in the flame | |||
*** MDN typeface is hard to read, we need to stick to something that will work at various sizes and that will work well in many different applications | |||
*** I like the fact that it stands out on its own and inside a rounded block | |||
*** I like the color theme of red, white, black and gray | |||
** Comp 2: Robo Dino | |||
*** Typeface doesn't seem to fit, it feels too much like the QMO logo font | |||
*** Dino looks cool, but not sure about the wrench in the mouth... feels a bit cheesy | |||
*** If we do go with the Robo Dino, it will be nice to have a more accurate conversion from the Mozilla Dino head | |||
** Comp 3: Pixelated | |||
*** I like the concept, but think it needs to be polished a bit more. | |||
*** MDN looks cool in pixels, but again too hard to read. We could fix that though | |||
*** I do like the <> brackets and // slashes | |||
*** Maybe too simple? Needs something more visual to go with it. | |||
** Comp 4: Eye | |||
*** I like the font A LOT. It is clean, modern, techy and easy to read. I think this should be the typeface we use with any new comps to see if it works... also interested in seeing "MDN" in that style. | |||
*** I don't get the eye... so looking forward to hearing the designers rationale | |||
** Comp 5: Dino Gears | |||
*** Looks too much like a toy, not professional enough | |||
*** MDN typeface appears to be too complicated, though I do like the way the letters "fit" together. I was hoping for a similar approach, but in a more 3D cube or puzzle design. | |||
*** Gear just feels too cliche. | |||
** Comp 6: Spidey Sense | |||
*** Again the typefase seems to work well | |||
*** I like that we can put it in a rectangular block and it looks good in monochrome | |||
*** Reminds me of spiderman... which is cool, but not the right direction for MDN. Maybe if we tried a similar design, but using all the letters in MDN? | |||
** Comp 7: Workers | |||
*** Not a huge fan of the typeface here, reminds me of the font in Comp 2. | |||
*** Love the fist logo... as it is shown on the main Comp 7 page (with wrench/lightening + circle + no nails on fingers), but it also looks good without the circle, which is nice. | |||
*** Fingers form an "M" to me... which is cool. | |||
*** I like the alternatives with the wrench only and the wrench+lightening... BUT just the lightening doesn't work. Looks a bit weird. | |||
*** I like the arrangement of "Mozilla Developer Network" on the complete logo + wordmark designs... nice to have options. | |||
*** This is probably my favorite, but it would be better with: 1. Typeface from Comps 4 & 6, 2. | |||
** Comp 8: Atom | |||
*** Doesn't seem like a good fit for MDN | |||
*** Don't get the atom concept, so looking forward to hearing the designers rationale | |||